Restaurant Review: Charlie Bird Part II

Jeremy and I went back to one of our top spots, Charlie Bird, in the West Village. The first time we had a really great experience, and this time was no different. Service was outstanding, as expected, and we had a really lovely evening celebrating 4 years together.

The food and drink line up was as follows...

I wanted to try a new cocktail this time, so I went with the Last Word, which is gin, lime, maraschino, and chartreuse. Jeremy stuck with his Old Pal, made with rye, vermouth, and campari. Both were delicious and strong.

Left: Last Word
Right: Old Pal

We started in the raw section with the Long Island Fluke. This came as a plate full of extremely thinly sliced pieces of raw fluke dressed in olive oil and probably lemon or something tangy, topped with almonds and delicious pickled tomatoes. I love pickled veggies and this was first experience with pickled tomatoes - they were great. The fish was very fresh and I enjoyed this dish, but because the pieces were so thin, the amount of fish you actually get is pretty minimal.

Raw Long Island Fluke

Next was the Tuscan Chicken Liver, served with balsamic raisins, capers, walnuts, and crispy bread to spread it on. I already raved about the liver last time, but I will reinforce that this is the best liver I've ever had. It's not your typical irony liver. It is well seasoned, smooth, and mild. It's an all around wonderful starter.

Tuscan Chicken Liver

Next was the pasta dish. While we liked the Duck Egg Spaghetti the first time, we wanted to try something else. So, we went with the Spaghettini Nero with Dungeness crab, chilies, and Meyer lemon. The black pasta was homemade and there was a decent amount of crab. I wouldn't say this was the most flavorful dish of the night, but it was enjoyable. I would definitely recommend the Duck Egg Spaghetti over this one though.

Spaghettini Nero

Our entree and side came out together - braised rabbit and cauliflower. The braised rabbit was cooked and seasoned nicely, not too gamey. It was served on top of a hash of spring onions, pancetta, and fava beans. Good texture and interesting ingredient combination. I liked this dish while Jeremy REALLY liked it.

Braised Rabbit

The side of cauliflower was "caramelized" and served with pancetta, almonds, and olio nuovo (a type of oil). Because the menu said it was caramelized, I was expecting more of a sticky/sweet situation, but it was actually kind of dry. While I liked the pancetta and almonds flavor combination, I have to admit I had higher hopes for this one.

Caramelized Cauliflower

We went for dessert this time around, and since pignoli cookies are Jer's favorite, the Gelati & Pignoli caught his eye. We had a few choices of gelati and went with the olive oil flavor. This was a fantastic choice, and they were very generous with the portion. The pignolis were fine, but since Jer has such high standards for this cookie, it didn't quite live up to his expectations. It was still good though, don't worry.

Olive oil gelati and pignoli cookies

We had a lovely anniversary dinner with great food in a fun, yet quiet(ish) atmosphere. Since the menu is not huge, I think we have exhausted everything we wanted to try and probably won't rush back again so soon. However, I would still strongly recommend this spot if you haven't been, so go check it out!